The Cayman Islands' Special Trusts Alternative Regime (STAR) Trusts, unique to the jurisdiction, represent a significant evolution in trust law.Here's a comparative analysis of STAR Trusts and similar trust models in other jurisdictions.
Key Features of Cayman Islands STAR Trusts
1. Statutory Trust: A STAR Trust is a statutory form of trust established for persons, charitable or non-charitable purposes, or both, as defined under the Special Trusts (Alternative Regime) Law 1997.
2. Flexibility in Purposes: They can be set up for any kind or number of purposes, as long as they are lawful and not against public policy.
3. No Perpetuity Period: Unlike other trusts in the Cayman Islands,STAR Trusts are not subject to the general 150-year perpetuity period, allowing for the creation of perpetual trusts.
4. Role of an Enforcer: A distinctive feature is the introduction of an "Enforcer," who is responsible for the trust's enforcement, separating the enjoyment of trust assets from the responsibility of enforcement.
5. Trust Corporation Requirement: A Trust Corporation, licensed in the Cayman Islands, must be a trustee.
6. Uses: Common uses include dynastic trusts, acting as a trustee of a Private Trust Company (PTC), running family businesses, restricting beneficiary information access, Special Purpose Vehicles (SPVs), and philanthropic purposes.
7. Drafting Challenges: Drafting the trust's purposes requires meticulous attention to meet specific standards.
8. Global Recognition: Concerns about the global recognition of STARTrusts have been unfounded, with no reported cases challenging their validity internationally.
Comparable Models in Other Jurisdictions
While there are various trust structures around the world, few match the unique characteristics of the STAR Trust. However, some jurisdictions offer trusts with features that resonate with aspects of the STAR Trust:
1. Liechtenstein Foundation: Similar to a trust, it allows for asset protection and estate planning. It is a legal entity that can serve both charitable and private purposes, akin to the dual-purpose nature of STARTrusts.
2. New Zealand Foreign Trust: Offers tax advantages for non-residents and allows for a broad range of purposes, paralleling the flexibility of STAR Trusts.
3. Delaware (USA) Dynastic Trusts: These trusts can have perpetual terms, similar to the STAR Trust’s lack of a perpetuity period. They are often used for wealth preservation across generations.
4. Singapore Variable Capital Companies (VCCs): While not trusts,VCCs offer flexibility for asset management and investment funds, akin to theSTAR Trust's use as SPVs in structured finance.
Conclusion
The Cayman Islands STAR Trust stands out for its flexibility, the unique role of the Enforcer, and its adaptability for various purposes, including those not strictly charitable. While other jurisdictions offer trusts or trust-like entities with some overlapping features, the STAR Trust's combination of flexibility, perpetual duration, and enforcer role remains distinctive. This uniqueness contributes to its appeal in global wealth management and estate planning contexts.
Sign up to our newsletter and get tips and tricks inbox
We promise. No spam. Only high quality content, exciting news and useful tips and tricks from the team.